Sugee Cookies – Makes Melt-in-Your-Mouth Magic!
Sugee cookies are very light, crumbly, oh-so-very-buttery, melt-in-your-mouth cookies. These are festive favourites, but perfect treats for everyday tea.
I can’t possibly start my Lunar New Year without sugee cookies!
My festive baking this year has seen better progress than most, with lapis cakes and pineapple tarts all done, and now, with just three more days to the start of the New Year, I quickly get to baking these light, crumbly, and oh-so-very-buttery ghee cookies.
Sugee cookies are like a very lightweight version of shortbread cookies.
Biting into a sugee cookie, you first feel a crisp crunch, and the cookie quickly breaks into crumbly morsels, releasing an intense buttery flavour (as ghee is used instead of butter), and it all literally melts in your mouth.
It’s a sublime way to enjoy a cookie, don’t you agree?
Sugee cookies are very easy to bake (yes, believe me – finally, here’s a Chinese New Year goodie that doesn’t have to test our baking skills to the hilt!).
These cookies tend to have characteristic cracks in their appearance, and that’s due to the action of baking soda when mixed into the cookie dough.
I tend to defer to traditional Nonya recipes like this one by the late Mrs Leong Yee Soo, which uses the simplest of ingredients, and omits the use of baking soda.
If you love surface cracks in your sugee cookies, mix in 2 to 2 1/2 tsp of baking soda with the flour, before adding to the ghee mixture. Then proceed as per the recipe instructions, and shape into rounds without making impressions.
DID YOU KNOW?
Ghee is clarified butter — the butter oil, without the lactose and other milk solids. It is traditionally prepared by gently heating butter until it becomes a clear golden liquid.
The lactose and other milk solids coagulate and are meticulously removed. This process also evaporates most of the natural water content, making ghee light, pure and resistant to spoilage (source: www.qbbghee.com).
Perhaps, the only challenge you’re likely to face is the temptation to over-bake these cookies, and trust me, it’s easy to over-bake these.
You’ll tend to want to see the cookies brown a little, as most cookies and biscuits do, but these cookies should turn lighter, to a pale cream colour when baked (and I know that this might go against every impulse or instinct you have as a baker).
If they are over-baked, these cookies become hard, crispy and crunchy, though still delicious, and are perfectly edible.
If baked to a pale cream, these cookies will give you that full buttery taste of ghee, and that much sought after, characteristic, melt-in-your mouth texture.
Sugee Cookies
Ingredients
- 400 g ghee
- 300 g confectioner’s sugar
- 700 g plain flour
- 1 tsp vanilla essence
- ¾ tsp salt
Instructions
- In an electric mixer fitted with a paddle attachment, cream ghee confectioner’s (icing) sugar, essence, and salt on medium speed for 5 minutes. Change to a dough hook attachment, add the flour, and knead into a soft dough. Leave covered for 4 hours.
- Pre-heat oven to 120 deg C (250 deg F). Line baking trays with greaseproof paper.
- Using a teaspoon, scoop a heaped teaspoon portion of dough and roll between your palms into a ball, each the size of a marble. Place on the baking tray, spaced well apart. Using a small fork, make impressions by pressing lightly on the centre of each ball, and sliding the fork away from the centre to prevent sticking. (For round-shaped cookies, roll into balls, and press lightly in the centre with your finger).
- Bake for 20 – 25 minutes, until cookies turn lighter in colour. Transfer to a cooling rack. When completely cooled, store in airtight containers.
First time trying Celia’s recipe. It’s delicious! Melts in the mouth ! I let the dough rest for 4 hrs and I believe this really made a difference in the texture.
Hi Sue, I’m so thrilled this worked out to your satisfaction. Thank you so much for taking the time to write a review!
Hi, I’ve tried, but never rest it and doesn’t give that kind of taste & It doesn’t have a melt-in-the-mouth quality..wanna try again. Need to leave the dough in the fridge or at room temperature? Pls advice..Usually I add almond nibs to it.
Hi Krishna, you can rest the dough at room temperature in a cool place, covered with cling wrap. Resting the dough is recommended to allow the gluten in the flour to relax (gluten makes the cookies tough/hard). Also, the cookies will only have a melty quality if they are slightly under-baked. So you need to take them out of the oven when they are still pale but not moist. Just an option, if you like cracks in the cookies, mix in 2 to 2 1/2 tsp of baking soda with the flour before adding to the ghee mixture. Hope this helps!
Hi Celia, love your recipe so much . Taste so good . Just one question, can i use Sugee flour to replace the plain flour?
Hi Celia,
Can I use butter or vegetable ghee for the recipe?
Hi Charmaine, I’ve never made these cookies with butter. I reckon because butter has water content (20% water, 80% fat) whereas ghee is 100% clarified fat, using butter may not give these cookies that light, melt-in-your-mouth texture. Vegetable ghee tends to lack the rich, buttery flavour of pure ghee so I wouldn’t recommend it either unless it cannot be helped. Hope this helps answer your question!
Hi Celia, Can I add almond pieces to the sugee cookies. May I know how much to add to your recipe pls. Many thanks and kind regards.
Hi Doris, for a nutty texture, I would probably add about 25% of the weight of flour. This ratio is in relation to the total weight of the flour, so if you make the full recipe which uses 700 gram of flour, add 25% of 700 gm = 175 gm of crushed almond slices.
Thank you very much Celia. I will add the almond bits or maybe macadamias as it is a great compliment to the sugee cookies. Warm regards, Doris
Whenever I am in Singapore, I always dropped by Bengawan Solo to buy these sweet treats. I just finished baking it and we just can’t stop eating it. Very very close to bengawan solo’s sugee cookies. I did replace some of the flour with fine semolina flour. Hope there will still more when family comes over tomorrow. Thank you for sharing the recipe, Celia. Happy Chinese New Year to you & your family.
Hello Pert! Happy Chinese New Year to you too! Thank you so much for sharing, and I’m so thrilled you were able to recreate one of your favourite CNY goodies at home with this recipe! I’ve been meaning to update the recipe to include semolina flour as an essential ingredient too. You just gave me the impetus to do so soon!
May I know based on this recipe, roughly how my cookies can be made?
Look forward to bake
Hi Janice, it depends on the size of your cookies, but as per the recipe, you can get 200 cookies. You can easily half the recipe if that’s too many.
Should there be semolina flour in the sugee cookies?
Hi Carolyn, yes, you’re right that semolina flour is a traditional ingredient in sugee cookie. This recipe is one of the late Mdm Leong Yee Soo’s, one of Singapore’s culinary matriarchs, and I stayed true to it as printed in her cookbook.In my humble opinion, these cookies do turn out nice too.
Hi Celia,
Made it and it’s very tasty and pretty. Super easy, thanks for your recipes! Will try more.
May I know why my sugee cookies are a bit hard? My friends say it’s tasty but a bit hard.
Hi Shu, thank you so much for trying these cookies! If it’s a bit hard after it cools, it’s probably been baked a little too long. It happened to me the first few times I baked these, cos I’m so used to waiting for my cookies to brown a bit. But this is the opposite, the cookies should be slightly underbaked and still look pale. They they’ll turn out with more melt-in-the-mouth quality. Hope this helps!
Hi there, I did the same as per measurement given but the dough is so watery and it is impossible for me to make it into a ball? any idea?
Hello Arvina, sorry to hear but this dough should not be turning out watery with the ingredients listed – ghee, icing sugar and flour are all firm at room temperature. The cookie dough is indeed soft but can easily be shaped into balls. The only thing I can think of is that possibly, the mixture was creamed at too high a speed, creating heat and causing some of the ghee to melt. I would recommend chilling the dough until it’s firm enough to shape.
What happens if i don’t leave it for 4 hours? Maybe ard 2 hours?
Hi Shahira, I think resting between 2 to 4 hrs should be fine! Hope these turn out to your liking !
Thanks Celia for the advice. I had some problems with my oven but managed to resolve the issue and ended up baking all the dough without having to keep it for another day. The results were fantastic! Thank you for sharing the recipe 🙂
Hi Noridah! I’m so glad these worked out well! Thank you for taking the time to write in and share! Selamat Hari Raya!???
Hi Celia
Is it possible to keep the dough in the fridge to bake at another time?
Hi Ida, I haven’t chilled this dough before but I think it should be okay to do so. But I would only do so overnight. Unlike other types of cookies which you can bake right out of the chiller, I would allow the dough to come to room temperature before rolling and baking. Hope this works out well for you!?
Hi. Can i leave the dough overnight?
Hi Jing, I’ve never left this cookie dough overnight but it should be fine, as the dough doesn’t contain eggs or dairy. I would keep it covered in a dry, cool place. Hope you could share how it turns out! Happy baking!
First time baking cookies and i love the outcome. QBB ghee brand is a must. I used regular cake mixer to blend ghee and sugar then kneaded flour in by hand till dough got nice and even. Rested dough for abt 3 hours. Cookies were smooth, no cracks, and yes that oh-so-buttery-melt-in-the mouth feeling…100% must try sugee cookies recipe, thanks to Celia.
Hi Shanks, I can’t believe I missed replying to your comment! I know this is coming so late, but thank you so much for trying out these cookies, and sharing how you did it. I always use QBB brand of ghee too, just love the flavour! Please keep your comments coming (and I’ll try to reply asap…?)
No sugee for this recipe?
Hi Kavan, there is no semolina flour in the recipe which I realise is odd for these to be called sugee cookies. It’s how the original recipe was presented and I didn’t feel the need to tweak it then as these cookies really do turn out awesome and have that melt-in-the mouth texture.
Hi Celia, I tried your recipe today but I halved all the ingredients. I roll them into balls but minutes later my cookies were flattened in the oven, I was shocked when I saw that. I’m not sure why. Can I replace icing sugar with raw sugar? Why do you rest your dough for 4 hours?
Hi Amelia, sorry to hear that. I’ve not encountered this before but my immediate thoughts would be that it’s possibly a case of over creaming the ghee. Do not replace icing sugar with raw sugar as the texture will turn out differently. Cookie dough, when rested enough, allows the flour to become coated evenly with the fats and gluten (protein) in the flour to relax, so that the cookies can have the melt-in-the-mouth texture. Resting also allows the flavours to develop better, so the cookies will taste nicer. Hope this helps!
Hi Celia,
Thanks for sharing your recipe. Do you think substituting some of the flour with ground almonds will work?
Appreciate your comments. Thanks
Hi Pat, thank you for writing in!?I haven’t tried that myself though cashew sugee cookies are made with flour and ground cashew, so I’m sure ground almonds would work just as well. Nut-based sugee cookies would have more of a crunch to it than a melt-in-the mouth texture. Hope this helps!
hi, thank you for sharing. i am cooking half of the recipe, do i leave the dough covered for 2 hrs or 4hrs?
Appreciate your advise as my dough has just crossed 1hr ?
Hi Violet, I usually let mine rest for 4 hours, but if you can’t wait that long, I would let it rest it for at least 2 hours. Mine were worth the wait, they turned out crisp on the outside but melt-in-the-mouth, if baked just right. Hope your cookies turn out great too! Hope you can share!?
Thanks for the response. I am certainly going to wait for 4 hrs to get the ultimate taste. ?
Hello, can I know if I bake the cookies at the lowest level or the medium level of the oven? Is it top and n bottom heat or just bottom heat?
Hi Jo, I baked top and bottom heat, on the middle oven rack. Hope it works out beautifully!
Hi Celia,can we make an additional cheese flavor in the ghee cookies??
Hi Nicole,mmmm… yummm,cheese sugee cookies sound so good!??? I haven’t tried this before so I can’t be sure how to tweak this. I’d love to know if you do make a cheese version though!
If my electric mixer does not have paddle or dough hook attachment, can I cream the wet ingredients with wooden spoon? Do I need to use icing sugar to get’melt-in-mouth’ effect? After browsing your recipe-I recalled successfully making sugee biscuits in 6-3-3 proportion. Can’t remember if I have to use icing sugar or fine sugar will do?
Hi Celia
Does this recipe require baking soda?
Hi Shini, if you like the crack appearance in your cookies, mix in 2 to 2 1/2 tsp of baking soda with the flour, before adding to the ghee mixture. Then proceed as per the recipe instructions, and shape into rounds without making impressions. Hope this helps!
hi Celia,
I’m gonna make this tonight and does the recipe have the quality of melts in the mouth, because the previous recipe i used to do doesn’t give that kind of taste
hope to hear you soon .
Thank you in advance
Hi Shini, thank you for writing! It does have a melt-in-the-mouth quality if you are careful not to overbake, but it will be crisp on the outside.?
Hi Celia,
Have you experience with different brand of ghee? Which is the better tasting?
Hi Jenny, I’ve only made these with two brands widely available in Singapore, QBB and LEILA. Both worked out equally well in terms of flavour, in my humble opinion, though I use QBB more often for most of my baking and cooking.?
Hi,
Just to let you know, in your method you have forgotten to add the vanilla and salt. It got me a little confused and I had to add it at the end before baking.
Hi Sarah, oh my! Thank you so much for highlighting that! Sorry forbthe confusion, am going to edit the recipe to include that right away! Hope your cookies turned out to your liking!?
Hi Sarah, sorry for the confusion!? hope you liked how your cookies turned out! Thank you for highlighting that, and I’ve updated the recipe. ?
Did you leave the dough in fridge ?
Hi Adeeba, I left the dough out at room temperature.☺
thank you for the recipe , my mom love it so much .
That’s so nice to hear!? Thank you so much for trying this recipe! Enjoy!?
Sorry for too many questions,did you sift the flour and icing sugar?
Hi Adeeba, I usually do out of habit but you don’t need to for cookies. For cakes, it’s more important.?
What do you mean by using a moderate oven ?
As per the instruction, pre-heat oven to 120 deg C (moderately hot) and bake at this temperature. Sorry for the confusion!? I’ll clear that up in the recipe. Thanks, Adeeba!
Can I divide this recipe by 2 ?
Hi Adeeba, sure you can! This recipe is easily halved. Hope you like it!
Is there any possibility to over knead the dough after you add the flour ?
Hi Adeeba, you only need to knead long enough to incorporate the flour, which shouldn’t take very long if I remember correctly.
Can i use normal spoon to mix instead of electric mixer??
Hi Yasin, yes, you can, you’ll get a little exercise doing it by hand?! It would be a lot easier if you could use a spoon/scoop/spatula with a long handle to beat the ghee and icing sugar mixture till it’s light and fluffy, then use your hands to knead in the flour.
Very nice nd simple
Thank you, Mallika!?
Thanks for your special tips to leave the dough covered for 4 hours. This makes the biscuits melt in the mouth.
Thank you so much, Doris!? So happy to hear that!
Hi my cookies using this receipe was a hit and brought back childhood memories. However the top layer was a little sticky like uncooked.
I tried moving the trays up and down . Maybe next round I will do it in smaller balls
Cheers
Hi Su Yin,
So happy to hear that! Thank you for sharing!? I recall that mine had a kind of a powdered sticky surface too, was it like that for you? I thought that was characteristic of sugee cookies, otherwise, they might end up being overbaked and crunchy but still delicious!?
Hi Rachel. This seems like the perfect receipe but for some reaso n i am not able to see the most important ingredient which is the sugee. How much sugèe does one use for the main receipe written at the top ? Thank you.
Hi Daljit, this recipe doesn’t actually use semolina flour, which I know may seem odd ? you could easily experiment with it though, by using part plain flour, part semolina flour. The texture won’t be quite as melt-in-the-mouth, but I reckon it’ll have a nice crunch. Do let me know if you try it, ya? Cheers, Celia
Hi. May I know what if the cookies are too sweet. What else can I do ?
Hi Michelle, I know the amount of icing sugar looks insane ? but these cookies won’t turn out tasting sickly sweet, also because there’s salt added that blunts the sweetness just a tad. Do feel free to reduce the sugar if you’d prefer the cookies a little less sweet. You may need to reduce the salt a pinch too.?
Ooh! Finally a recipe that doesn’t call for 1:2 ghee to flour. I’ve been experimenting with Sugee cookies this year too and had some trouble getting them fully cooked without any browning – I’ll have to try your lower oven temp on my next batch. 🙂 thanks!
Hi Rachel, hope the texture of these sugee cookies as per the recipe works out to your liking, and if it’s not too much trouble, I’d love to hear from you how it turns out when you try this…happy baking!?
Didn’t have time to do 120C/20-25 min so I just tried a middle ground of 150C or thereabouts for about 16-17 min and they turned out great! My house is now out of ghee which…is probably a good thing since I cannot stop eating these things haha but I’ll definitely try 120C next time I make these! Thanks 🙂
Hi Rachel, thanks so much for sharing! That’s awesome! Now I know what to do if I’m short on time too! 🙂 Regards, Celia
Yeah they weren’t as snowy white as yours were (but that’s probably also because I just melt the ghee and stir it into the sifted dry ingredients instead of creaming the ghee and sugar so the dough doesn’t start out as pale either). I definitely need to try the creaming method, but fwiw melting and stirring (plus the 150C bake temp + time) gets you from start to finish in about 25 minutes total so it’s a great shortcut with less cleanup and (I think anyway) a pretty good texture!
For reference my ingredients were….60g ghee, 1/2 tsp vanilla, 105g flour, 25g icing sugar, 1/2 tsp salt and 1/2 tsp baking powder.
That’s so helpful to know, Rachel! Thanks a ton for sharing in detail how you made these. I’d definitely love to try it the way you did yours. I think it works out really well both ways, from what I’ve read elsewhere when looking for recipes for these cookies (i.e. melting the ghee, then stirring in the dry ingredients, or creaming the ghee with sugar and then kneading in the dry ingredients), but I’d happily go for a shortcut method anytime! Happy eating (am getting fat on my stock of these cookies!)